Home › News › Local News
Cash-strapped Water Valley school district cuts 9 jobs
Water Valley
STORY TOOLS
More Local News
- San Angelo Stadium field house project gets under way
- San Angelo-area lake levels, 01/09
- San Angelo-area jail bookings,01/09
Social Bookmarking
WATER VALLEY - Its effort to raise taxes thwarted by a mere 26 votes, the Water Valley school board on Monday cut nine positions, slashing 14 percent of the school district's staff in an effort to close a budget deficit projected at more than a quarter-million dollars.
Teachers in physical education, agriculture and art are among those affected, as was the district's lone nurse.
The 7-0 vote came in a somber meeting, with the faces of dozens of onlookers alternating between anger and grim resignation as the board agreed to eliminate the positions, costing seven teachers and another staff member their jobs at semester's end.
"As much as I'd like to say there's a good solution, there's not," Superintendent Jimmy Hannon told the board. "The school is the heart of the community. We don't want it to go away."
Declining enrollment and legislative changes to the funding formula for small rural school districts have led to a projected deficit of $350,000 - too large to be significantly reduced by efforts in recent months to consolidate bus routes, freeze program budgets and conserve energy, Hannon said.
Average daily enrollment has dropped this school year to 314 students - down from a high of 338 in the 2006-07 year - but staffing has increased during that period from 60 to 65, Hannon told the board.
Hannon inherited a financial situation worse than he knew when the board hired him in August. In an effort to avoid layoffs, the district proposed a tax rollback election, hoping to win voter approval for a $1.17 property-tax rate, up 13 cents per $100 of property value from the current capped rate of $1.04.
Voters rejected the proposal Nov. 4 by a slim margin - 26 votes out of 673 cast in Coke and Tom Green counties, a margin the board certified Monday, minutes before turning to the business Hannon said the vote required.
Of the nine positions, one was empty following a resignation earlier in the year, Hannon said. Of the remaining eight, seven are staffed by certified teachers, he said. The terminations are effective Jan. 7, to give the teachers enough time to be credited with a full year under the Texas Retirement System, but they will not return after the school's Christmas break.
The board cut these positions:
n Elementary teachers in grades three through six
n Elementary computer instructor
n Elementary physical education
n High school agriculture
n High school art
n School nurse
None of the programs involved in the decision will be cut, Hannon said; rather, they will be staffed by teachers from other areas.
The motion passed by the board noted that athletics programs were excluded from the cuts, a paragraph that led to concern among the trustees.
"I don't know why the athletics department is off-bounds," said board Vice President Ricki Gochenauer. "I know we're short of coaches. I just hope we don't put athletics ahead of academics."
With only four coaches for the district's athletics programs, golf already having been cut and tennis seemingly next in line, Hannon said there simply was no more room for cuts in athletics.
"The primary focus when I went through this ... at all times has been on (preserving) the academic programs," he replied. "I know it's great to win district in football ... or basketball or volleyball or whatever. To me, none of that measures up to an exemplary rating."
Participants and observers alike seemed weighed down with the gravity of the impending decision.
Opening the meeting with public comment, Janet Wood, in her seventh year teaching elementary physical education, pleaded unsuccessfully for her job.
"I'll do whatever it takes to stay in the position," she said. "If I have to take a pay cut, whatever it takes, if there's any possible way for the kids to continue to have P.E."
A parent, Theresa Bird, also spoke, reading from handwritten notes with a voice choked by emotion.
"If it weren't for them," Bird said of the district's teachers, "our children would not have the best TAKS scores in the area. They're not just teachers. They are also someone (children) can turn to, get a hug from, turn to in a time of need."
There are 21 responses to this story. Click here to join the conversation
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned.
- First-time hunter gets 2 bucks after shooting just 1
- Injured Christoval basketball player turns to notable doctor
- RICK SMITH: Traveling West Texas by computer
- Ex-Tech QB hired as coach
- San Angelo man dies in vehicle crash
- School Matters, 01/06
- Base may add mission
- RICK SMITH: Readers love or hate Street View
- Foster Field auction delayed
- Book shop in San Angelo mall set to close

- Keep it on topic. Comments that are obscene, vulgar, lewd or sexually-oriented will be removed. Creative spelling of such terms also will be filtered out and banned.
- Do not threaten to hurt or kill anyone. Not only is this illegal, but violates our user agreement.
- Be truthful. Don't lie about anyone or anything. Exposing untruthful things is not what comments are about.
- Be nice. No racism, sexism or any other sort of -ism that degrades another person.
- Keep it local. Do not post direct links to sites outside of gosanangelo.com.
- Police yourselves. Hit the "Suggest Removal" button on offensive comments. We, in turn, will take a look at your issue with a particular comment and remove it if it violates our user agreement.
- Share what you know. Give us your eyewitness accounts, background, observations and history. You are our eyes and ears in the Concho Valley.
- Ask questions. What more do you want to know about the story? We can then forward your question to the appropriate person and have them give you a response.
- Help us get it right. If you find a factual error or misspelling within one of our stories, email webmaster@gosanangelo.com before slamming the writer and newspaper.
- Gosanangelo.com reserves the right to suspend the comments function without prior notification, including but not limited to: repeated violations of the user agreement, conversations straying off topic, and/or protection of minors.
By following these simple rules, we can keep comments alive and allow you, our residents and loyal readers, the privilege of being able to voice opinions on local issues.Click here for our full user agreement.
Posted by Cricket on November 18, 2008 at 9:45 a.m.
WHY IS WATER VALLEY KEEPING AN UNFUNDED PRE-K CLASS IF THEY ARE IN THIS MUCH FINANCIAL CRISIS?
Why WV is not even considering slashing the gravy first--things like the pre-K class? This class, just this year, was made open to the anyone living in the district, as opposed to just those who were economically disadvantaged or mentally/physically handicapped/etc. How much money is it costing WV EVERY DAY to subsidize structured daycare for those kids?? This class will not be nearly as missed as art, ag, and, for crying out loud in a world struggling with obesity, P.E. The older children do not deserve having their classes eliminated in order to float a new pre-K program. The kids in pre-K have their whole elementary education ahead of them. Pre-K has waited this long; it can wait until WV is financially strong enough to maintain it.
If these fine professionals are being asked to walk away from their careers in the middle of the school year with little chance of finding another teaching job until summer nears, I would expect those at the top of this stinking heap to step up to the plate in full force. I understand the principal's wife is teaching the pre-K, and they have children in this class. I understand this principal and his band director have a long history together, and the principal hired the band director's wife as the band director's teacher's aid, and this couple also has a child in this pre-K class. At the absolute very least, someone owes the public a rock-solid explanation to justify why that UNFUNDED pre-K is not being dropped FIRST.
On a personal note, Mrs. Wood is not your average P.E. coach--each year she organizes the HEB Camp for all 5th and 6th grade students. This camp has given kids an opportunity to explore and learn so much about culture and science outside the classroom in a way that is both memory making and absolutely breathtaking. This GIFT will surely fall by the wayside when she is forced out the door. Many of these kids would never have this hands-on opportunity outside of her program. She organizes yearlong fund raising and coordinates much of the entire project with help from her colleagues and parents. She and her family are also deeply invested in WV outside of school functions--to push them out the door a week before Christmas like this is a tragedy for students, teachers, and parents alike.
MEMBERS OF THE BOARD: I do not envy you for the road you have recently traveled or the crossroads ahead. Please do not let the administration pressure you into doing anything if there's any other way this situation can be mitigated. This is not just teacher's jobs--it's about programs' futures, neighbors' livelihoods, childrens' mentors. The solutions proposed cut through the very fabric of our community. Please take your time and thoughts outside of the box handed to each of you last night and reconsider all other options first.
My prayers and best wishes go out to all involved.
Posted by blueajax on November 18, 2008 at 10 a.m.
I don't understand why people are sad. I thought everyone was against raising taxes (you know, like Socialists apparentely do).
Posted by CountryBunny36 on November 18, 2008 at 10:32 a.m.
It's my opinion that the money has been there, just isn't being managed right. As far as I'm concerned, cutting Nurse Gilstrap was the final straw...you'll not be seeing my kids at Water Valley any more! They will go back to Wall where they KNOW HOW TO MANAGE THEIR MONEY!
Posted by kassandra.minton on November 18, 2008 at 11:32 a.m.
My heart is saddened - what is happening at Water Valley is soon to be world wide. We have all lived beyond our means and given our work loads to others to help us and to also help create(in some cases)un-needed positions/jobs. Now that times are rough we want to point fingers and accuse those in power. I want to truly believe that a lot of thought and praying has gone into this decision. We have a new Superintendent and he is unfamaliar with any of our past history, teachers, etc. He does want whats best for our Students - that is where our main concern should lie. The past administration was not held accountable by our School Board - I did make meetings and felt we had a yes man crew. I don't want them to micro manage - but when it comes to spending tax payers dollars and you have business men on the position of School Board Member - I feel they need to take the same responsibility they do in their jobs - if they can look back over the past few years and be able to look you in the eye and tell you we did our best - we checked out the situatioins and made the chioces we felt were most advantageous for Water Valley ISD and the Students that attend - we want to blame the top dog - when lots of times that dog can only do what the little dogs allow. Let's quit pointing fingers, we need to rally to the support of this sittuation and come together as a community and make a difference. Life is hard - we want it all with as little effort as possible put into it. You know if you fight all your battles and never have to hit your knees and call upon the Lord to help - then your not getting the message - quit telling eveyone how big your problems are and start telling everyone how big your God is.
I am praying for the outcome and asking for God's Grace - Love and understanding for all who are involved and the domino effect it will have on our community.
Posted by ourbabygirl on November 18, 2008 at 1:27 p.m.
Just curious why the Ag program was cut before band. I mean Water Valley is a 6 man program, how many 6 man programs have a band, none. Wouldn't ag be more benefical because this is an agriculture community and some of these kids work or live on a ranch or farm.
Getting rid of the school nurse, hope there is never a need for a student to be monitored or have a child on campus with a serious medical condition. Who will keep up with medication that has to be given to students during the school day because if it's the school office they are busy answering phones etc.
Posted by Cricket on November 18, 2008 at 1:37 p.m.
I was there last night, and as I listened to what was said by the board members, the superintendent, and the two women brave enough to provide public comment, I have absolutely no doubt a lot of thought and prayer has gone and continues to go into this.
That does not mean people in leadership positions should not be held accountable for their actions, past or present, as they determine the future for so many others in the community. Clearly, Mr. Hannon stepped into a firestorm, and I do not fault him. Others who have been here have some questions to answer though. These are questions I've heard many ask, yet they remain unaddressed.
Right now and until December 19th, it's time for action. A thorough review of all options should be done before we kick people to the curb, right before Christmas. Why not figure out a way to keep our teachers in place at least until the end of the school year when people have a proper opportunity to seek employment elsewhere? Why not review staffing levels at that time and adjust as necessary when teachers have a fair shot? I'm not suggesting WV does or does not have enough or too many staff--I'm requesting people be reasonable, considerate, and just before putting everyone involved in unnecessarily painful positions.
Posted by baker1564 on November 18, 2008 at 3:18 p.m.
I lived in Grape Creek and graduated from Lake View, I do not understand why Water Valley and Grape Creek have separate schools. Grape Creek, Carlsbad and Water Valley are not large enough for 2 schools. Water Valley should combine with Grape Creek and only have one school. The children that live on the north side of Water Valley can go to Sterling City. I know that there are children living in Grape Creek that go to Water Valley. Those children are bused to school every day. I don't understand financially how Grape Creek and Water Valley can survive much longer if they do not consolidate and try and save the tax payers money.
Posted by PointMan on November 18, 2008 at 5:15 p.m.
Wonder why the enrollment dropped so much?? Could it have anything to do with the current administration? The same administration that arrived in Water Valley in 2006/2007 when the enrollment decline started. I know serveral kids that have been kicked out of Water Valley by the principal. One kid was kicked out of school because of a technical foul in a basketball game. Instead of reaching out to the kid, that obviously needed some direction, the Water Valley administrator gave him a boot out the door the very next day. I know many that have moved their kids to Grape Creek because of the administration. Any school will have a decline in enrollment if they have a bully on the payroll. The thing that concerns me is the fact that it's been allowed.
Posted by PointMan on November 18, 2008 at 5:58 p.m.
It will be interesting to see who accually gets cut. Will the spouses of the board, or administration get cut. For now the only thing the board has done is voted to cut certian positions. Just because they voted to cut the elementary PE position doesn't mean that Mrs. Wood couldn't be reassigned to a position that keeps her employed. Same goes for the elementry computer position. We witnessed how easy the administrators can reassign the staff at Water Valley a few months ago. So do it again, but this time for right reasons. I'm sure they are qualified for other positions. These teachers have lived in the community for many years, raised their children in Water Valley, and own property in Water Valley. If they are cut, and the spouses of the administrators (which are new hires) are allowed to stay the people of Water Valley need to make a stand. Don't get me wrong I have anything against the spouses, they just haven't invested as much as some others have.
Posted by tonto on November 18, 2008 at 6:50 p.m.
in response to ourbabygirl
(This comment was removed by the site staff for violation of user agreement.)
Posted by Cricket on November 19, 2008 at 2:57 p.m.
in response to baker1564
With all due respect, as a graduate of Water Valley, your suggestion is an insult. WV is small, and that is why many people choose to send their children to school out there. There are transfers from several different schools for different reasons--some of which include the fact that these parents CHOOSE to send their kids to an academically stronger school. WV just built a new elementary addition and a new gym--what a waste of taxpayer money would it be to walk away from that investment!
This too shall pass. It's just a matter of people making sure things happen fairly and in the best interest of the community and students.
Posted by SaraSexton on November 19, 2008 at 7:08 p.m.
There is a meeting 11/20/08 in the Auditorium at 6:30pm. I hope all concerned community members will be in attendance.
Posted by gooberman on November 20, 2008 at 8:51 a.m.
It sounds like Cricket, ourbabygirl, and PointMan are all deeply concerned for the district. They both have alot of information about the district and seem to be pointing lots of fingers at the administration. It is my understandiung that the current administration and board tried to to pass a roll back election to prevent this sitution but the voters said "THANKS, BUT NO THANKS".
If you are truly concerned about the district
I would encourage you to visit with board members, district's administration, teachers, community members, and attend all board meetings.
This forum is definately a place to air your dirty laundry (without accountablity) but it is not a proper place where problems can be solved.
Of course what do I know, I am only Gooberman!
Posted by Cricket on November 20, 2008 at 9:17 a.m.
in response to SaraSexton
I will be out of town that night and cannot change plans on such short notice or I would be there...in a heartbeat. I've posted enough information for my friends to follow through however--that's what this forum IS good for. I do not believe I've aired dirty laundry--I've stated facts. I do plan to be there Monday night for the meeting.
Best of luck to all tonight! My thoughts and prayers are with all in Water Valley.
Posted by sam4877 on November 20, 2008 at 10:59 a.m.
Ok so now that the tax rollback failed by 26 votes, Is there a way to have a special election and see what could happen, WV people wake up and save your school, the small school's are falling by the way side all over america. Get all of the parents involved or in a few years there will be only 1 school out there and it will not be WV. What has happened to the oil & gas tax revenue that was coming in? When I lived there it was really quiet a lot of money.Any way good luck and get rid of pre-k and it will save a couple of the teachers positions.
Posted by gooberman on November 20, 2008 at 9:22 p.m.
ourbabygirl - Your comment above stated: "I mean Water Valley is a 6 man program, how many 6 man programs have a band, none."
Just FYI: I found a six man school in a couple of minutes that has a band - Throckmorton ISD. Check it out http://www.throck.org/vnews/display.v...
Your friendly neighborhood "gooberman"
Posted by Cricket on November 20, 2008 at 11:47 p.m.
in response to gooberman
Ironically, that is where the current WV principal and band direct came from prior to being hired in WV.
Posted by gooberman on November 21, 2008 at 9:10 a.m.
I encourage you to look at the band programs at Know City, O'Donnell, Eden, Robert Lee, May, Milford, etc... Are these all six man schools? Yes.
Cricket: Have the principal and band director have been at all these schools as well?
Basically, the quote by ourbabygirl is false.
According to rule #3 for this forum, posts must "be truthful. Don't lie about anyone or anything. Exposing untruthful things is not what comments are about."
Seek the whole truth,
Gooberman
Posted by sanangelonative on November 21, 2008 at 1:50 p.m.
Athletics, band, etc. are specialized electives that draw students in. Cut those, lose even more enrollment. They also have a way of improving grades, providing incentives for at-risk students to keep their grades up (no pass, no play). Not sure on the rationale behind cutting agriculture, but i presume that the administration balanced risks. Nevertheless, the community had a chance to save themselves from the cuts, but, nevertheless, they voted it down. I guess more folks are for it than against it....
Posted by floorman on November 22, 2008 at 4:15 p.m.
(This comment was removed by the site staff for violation of user agreement.)
Posted by lobo on November 23, 2008 at 7:03 a.m.
Some of us here in Eden are praying hard for you , Water Valley.
Posted by gooberman on December 1, 2008 at 11:46 a.m.
Dear Mr. Jones,
Your post should be removed from this forum! Your remarks are totally inappropriate and disrespectful.
Accorcing to the rules of this forum posts should "Be truthful. Don't lie about anyone or anything. Exposing untruthful things is not what comments are about. Be nice. No racism, sexism or any other sort of -ism that degrades another person."
Just my opinion,
Gooberman
Posted by tskinner on December 1, 2008 at 2:55 p.m.
in response to floorman
floorman,
you can prove this???
"....the fact that one of the newcomers from Throckmorton has been immoral with possibly three employees of the WVISD".
It would be truly immoral to make accusation like that without absolute irrefutable proof.
(Requires free registration.)
Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Violators may be banned. Click here for our full user agreement.